A walleye fishing outing on Oliver Reservoir in late June ended with a surprising result for Potter angler Jeremy Gasseling.

Gasseling, who was out on a boat in the body of water located west of Kimball, didn’t reel in the walleye he was aiming for. Instead, he caught a 46-inch tiger muskie

“I thought it was probably a catfish or a carp,” Gasseling said of his initial reaction. “I didn’t know for sure until it came up to the top. We didn’t know how we were going to get it in the boat because we didn’t have a net big enough.”

Gasseling, along with his fishing companion Kevin Frei, managed to land the whopper following a fight of about 15 minutes.

The species once was prevalent in the waters of Oliver Reservoir, but Gasseling said that hasn’t been the case recently.

“Oliver used to have a bunch of them until about 10 years ago when it dried up,” he said. “I thought they all died off, but I guess there’s still some in there.”

The catch netted Gasseling the grand prize in this year’s Star-Herald Biggest Fish Contest. He won a Cabela’s tailgate fillet table and a $100 gift card from Cabela’s.

Gasseling also won a $25 Cabela’s gift card for winning the tiger muskie species category.

A total of 49 entries were received during the contest, which began in May and ran through the end of August. Of the entries, 18 different species were represented. Each species winner receives a Cabela’s $25 gift card. The species winners can pick up their gift cards at the Star-Herald at 1405 Broadway in Scottsbluff.


Fish Species Category Winners

Bluegill — Matt Howlett of Scottsbluff

Brown trout — Scott Parker of Portales, New Mexico

Blue catfish — Rollie Parker of Dalton

Catfish — Brionna Schafer of Alliance

Crappie — Adyson Hoppes of Scottsbluff

European rudd — Brionna Schafer of Alliance

Largemouth bass — Devin Roach of Bridgeport

Muskie — Justin Powell of Alliance

Tiger muskie — Jeremy Gasseling of Potter

Northern pike — Troy Mach of Alliance

Perch — Matt Howlett of Scottsbluff

Rainbow trout — Doug Kozal of Alliance

Smallmouth bass — Kayla Carrizales of Gering

Sunfish — Tammy Standage of Alliance

Tiger trout — Raymond Lemoine of Mitchell

Walleye — Fred Hara of Scottsbluff; Robert Carrizales of Gering

White bass — Marissa Joekel of Gering

Wiper — Roger Murphy of Sidney

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.